The Mission Party has risen by mobilizing a young, sharp, online demographic which was traditionally checked out of politics. Victor Antoun explains how.
Transcript
Intro (00:00)
Wolf: Welcome back to The Students. So today is something a little different. We’re in Brazil. I’m here with some of the guys from Partido Missão, which is the Mission Party of Brazil. They are very interesting, young, new political party that I’ve become quite interested in.
And so I tracked down some of them here in Rio de Janeiro, and this is Victor Antoun, who is running for, what do you call it, state congress here?
Victor: Yeah. No, actually the national—
Wolf: The federal congress—in the state of Rio de Janeiro. All right. So Victor, welcome to the show.
Victor: Thank you so much for having me, Wolf. I’m big fan of your work on Palladium, right?
Wolf: Excellent.
Victor: It’s nice to be here. Very nice, actually.
Wolf: Yeah. Well, yeah, one of the reasons I’m interested in Partido Missão is they are Palladium readers.
Victor: Yeah. Many of us, really. Yeah.
Wolf: That’s very good. So, yeah. So I guess I got onto you guys, it was last year. We saw this wonderful article in J’accuse’s magazine called Meritocracy in Brazil. And it was like, “All right, this is interesting.”
Because when J’accuse says meritocracy, they mean something very interesting. So I thought, “Okay, that sounds cool,” and we read the article, and it described these young guys who are kind of doing all these antics to figure out how to fix Brazil, how to gain power within the corrupt system. And their charismatic leader, Renan Santos, and it all sounded very interesting. And so I said to my friend, “Well, we’ve got to get in touch with these guys. This sounds really interesting.”
And so we put out some feelers through our network, and it turned out Renan Santos and his friends were in town—in San Francisco. So they came to one of our parties, and they seemed like great guys, and they invited us down for the launch of the political party—which was last November. So in Brazil, it takes, what is it, 800,000 signatures to—
Victor: I think 500 something, yeah.
Wolf: Yes. 500,000 signatures—
Victor: 500,000
Wolf: to create a new political party. It’s actually quite an undertaking. So it was very impressive that these guys were able to do it, and they were launching that in November. It was a big rally. So I did decide to come down.
We went to São Paulo, and it was, as I said on Twitter at the time, it was the most glorious thing I’d ever seen.
Victor: Huge event for, like, 5,000 people, right? Yeah.
Wolf: Yeah. It was great. They had everyone up on the stage—trotting out the banners for all the—states. You guys had redesigned all the banners. You had some people beating on the drum.
Renan was waving around a sword on the stage. It was great.
Victor: Yeah. Soldiers go with... Yeah. It was a—
Wolf: It was, yeah, it was a lot of fun. So, and I said, “All right. I’ve got to come back next year for the election.” So here we are. That’s the background.
What is the Mission Party? (03:02)
Wolf: So Victor Antoun is running for office. And he’s one of the guys, and they’ve been running an impressive campaign here. So Victor, I’d love to hear from you. From your perspective in Brazil, what is Mission Party? Let’s start with that.
Victor: Yeah. Okay. Mission is a particularly new project, right? It doesn’t resemble anything that comes from the right in Brazil. Historically, the right in Brazil has been very physiological, very associated with local oligarchies and stuff, so it went through the military dictatorship without changing much.
It was very associated with the municipalities and stuff, so very no ideological in general.
Wolf: Non-ideological right. Yeah.
Victor: Yeah. It was ruling elites kept their power through a right-wing discourse, right? But it wasn’t truly right-wing, I mean, in the way it isn’t ideological. So we saw something very new because we have a program, ideology for the party. We are trying to do everything inside of it.
We have one leader. That’s... Yeah, that—
Wolf: We have the little yellow book here.
Victor: Yeah. Not so little anymore, but yeah. It was a huge research to try to diagnose what is wrong with Brazil, right? So we are starting with the whys. I don’t want to be cliché, but it was a nice entry to the political panorama in Brazil, right?
Through the book and through the launching of the party. So we are trying to keep it tech, young, smart, quick, and pragmatic also. So I’m very excited about the results that are coming in a week, right?
Wolf: Maybe. Right, it is just next week. Yeah, by the time this episode comes out, it probably will already have happened. We’ll see. We’ll see what happens.
But maybe a little bit on the history of the movement would be good. I understand it started, Renan Santos and his—brother kind of were involved in the protests against Dilma Rousseff back in the 2010s, and then the kind of core crew came together around that—the impeachment effort, and then maybe there was a dark period between then where they realized they needed to kind of develop that ideological self-construction. I’d love to hear it from you. I mean, you haven’t been around, I think, for that whole process, but—you maybe have a better inside story, right?
Victor: Sure. I talked with Renan a lot about the history of—MBL, right? I think it’s very important for us to situate ourselves in Brazilian history, so I try to do a historiography of MBL with him one day maybe. But it all started 10 years ago, maybe a little more, with the terrible presidency of Dilma Rousseff. It was Lula’s successor.
In a way, it was also deepening the populist sense, the socialist sense. So it was very problematic, but with the economic crisis that came by that time—manifestations and protests all over Brazil start to popping up, and Renan took control of a big group in São Paulo of protesters. And it all went by until Dilma fell. We got her impeached in 2016, I think. I’m not sure if I’m sure.
And then there was the onboarding on the Bolsonaro government. It was also very troublesome because since the beginning, Bolsonaro gave very bad signs about his intentions with Brazil and the way he wanted to rule things. He wasn’t particularly ideological also, so it soon became a problem. By that time, Jair Bolsonaro’s son, Flávio, who’s now running for president, was already going through many investigations. He was about to be arrested, and then Bolsonaro did anything he could to save his son.
It was maybe Bolsonaro’s first polemic. I’m not sure how to say this, but was the very first time Renan realized that Bolsonaro wasn’t the solution. So he departed from the government, almost got arrested, persecuted also. And then a few years later, he went back to the roots, popular roots of what got Dilma impeached and launched the Revista Valete, launched a YouTube channels. He tried to earn money and support to finally come through with the Missão party.
The institutional structure of the movement (07:58)
Victor: It was a—
Wolf: And this was the launch of Valete Magazine, the—the media operation basically. So as I understand it, Missão has three big parts now. There’s the original movement—which is this network of lots of energetic young people all across Brazil. Then there’s the Valete, the media empire, which kind of feeds on the movement and informs the movement. And now there’s Partido Missão—the actual political party that houses the politicians.
Victor: Yeah. Valete nowadays, it roots the movement in ideological stuff, or—the magazine, the channel, the cultural production that comes through it. But it is also very important financially. So it was essential from the beginning to start to have products, to have production, books. Valete nowadays is a big editor in Brazil also.
So that was a turning point. I got involved in Missão through Valete, right? I started out writing articles for their magazines. And now I’m running for Congress. So it wasn’t so simple, the transition there.
But, yes, those three spots and those three places to be inside our group, they feed on each other, right? Everyone puts a part in constructing a political party, I mean. In a way, Valete and MBL, they serve Partido Missão now. Yeah.
Wolf: Yeah, I want to talk about that kind of hierarchical relationship within the whole structure. As I understand it, Valete has kind of the geniuses in the back room cooking up the—core policy. Putting things into the little yellow book as sort of this is the ideology, this is how we’re going to approach the problems in Brazil. This is the party line, so to speak. And then that gets systematized through the discourse in articles, in streams—video, all kinds of stuff.
And it’s basically Renan, who’s in charge of everything, gets to kind of set the bounds on it and make the key decisions. And then that sort of ideologically disciplines the whole movement. Then you have the movement itself and its relationship to Renan and the politicians. I guess I don’t have as clear of a picture of that. I understand Renan is obviously the leader of the movement.
And then there’s the party. The party itself, I understand it’s kind of, as it was explained in the J’accuse article, or you can correct me if my interpretation of that was wrong, but it was basically that the politicians in Missão are not independent, sort of running with their own priorities. You’re using the office for the movement.
Victor: Yeah, sure. In Brazil, you can write your own, of course you can, but you can write your own internal laws for a party. But Missão is by far the most centralized, coherent one. So if I get elected into Congress and I don’t respect Partido Missão’s ideas in the, I can lose my office, right? I can lose my position.
And this operates in a whole sense. Everyone that is working around the MBL, Valete, and stuff is bound by our diagnostic of Brazil, right? So that’s very important. It’s a very important part of why I think the party is going places, I mean. Yeah.
Wolf: This is what makes it impressive, is that it’s this closed system, right? It’s vertically integrated. This is why I’m interested from the American perspective as well. It’s like, why do we care about what’s going on in Brazil? Brazil’s important, but it’s one of our hemispherical kind of neighbors—we have to get along, but I don’t think you guys are going to win this election.
I mean, look, not at the presidential level, let’s put it that way. But nonetheless, I think Missão is very important because you’re offering a new model—of what politics in our generation can look like, and this is something that I want our audience in the States to learn from. When a bunch of technocratic, ambitious, patriotic young people get together and create a highly effective political machine, what does that actually look like? And this is the best example I’ve seen of it, so I’m very curious.
Victor: Thank you for your kindness, Wolf. We try our best. But I think something that’s very important in Missão whole environment is everyone can bring something to it. In Valete, you have the more brainy types. In MBL, you have the more hands-on guys, doing everyday politics, shaking hands, and doing manifestations, protests.
And in Missão party, in my vision, the all-star league, the best ones—get elected, get into cabinets—start to work with the real thing. So—
Wolf: The rhetorical and strategic elite.
Victor: Yeah. So it’s very important to have everyone doing something. People nowadays, especially in our generation, they want to be part of something true, real, and they want to get stuff done. There are not many places where you can get real stuff done in Brazil nowadays. That’s one of the reasons of why I stopped being a lawyer.
I still have my qualifications to do it, but it’s not as engaging as having my own YouTube channel or running for Congress in Missão, right? Young people are eager to make history, be part of stuff. So—
Wolf: Yeah, I remember I saw this video clip of Renan saying basically, “You guys don’t just want to grill.” “You don’t just want to have a good life. You want to war.” If you look around—the world is screwed. You want to war.
And so, very inspiring. Renan’s great. But, maybe that’s a good place to jump off from to give us a little bit about the diagnosis, right? What is Missão’s diagnosis of Brazil? Why break with Bolsonaro?
Brazil needs to centralize (14:24)
Wolf: You mentioned the—some of the corruption stuff, but that fact that Missão is sort of on the right, but—schismed from Bolsonaro. From America, we look at Brazil and it’s like, “Oh yeah, we got the communists and we got the right-wing guy,” and like—that’s the choices. We have a very two-party mindset in America, right? But here’s Missão, this third party, kind of a very different approach. But I guess it all stems from your diagnosis, and the diagnosis colors the approach—as well.
So I’d love to hear you describe what’s wrong with Brazil.
Victor: Yeah. Brazil, it’s a third-world country, right? It’s not by coincidence. We have terrible political institutions, I would say first. The political comes before the economy, right?
My opinion, at least so. We went through the colony times, the empire times, the Republic, and our political class, political oligarchies, they never change. They don’t even have the intention to make Brazil something better. No way. They are very narrow-minded, localistic.
How do we say this in English? They are patrimonialistic also too much. So that is Brazil’s biggest problem. The parties, we have many of those. We have maybe 30.
I think there is 30 right now. But they don’t change too much if you go into the local level. There are two families buying votes, exchanging favors and stuff. That is the essential Brazilian problem—the basic one. Because of that, the whole country lacks ambition and drive to engage with real themes, not local themes.
That’s the first diagnosis of Missão, and now has a great project to try to solve this. That is Brazil’s greatest problem. But Renan has a great project. It’s called Lei de Responsabilidade Gerencial. He want to bring obligations into the funds that go into municipalities. That would be a great response, try to engage them into getting better education indexes, sanitation, security.
Wolf: So if I can restate that, basically, the problem is that Brazil does not have an ambitious national elite. There’s basically local elites and various corrupt—sort of patterns. And one of the solutions you’re talking about on that is to have priorities—kind of pushed out from the center to be—sort of competed over by the local provinces.
Victor: Perfectly. And also, we want to bring technical know-how into municipalities all around Brazil. Because imagine a 10,000 population city in the middle of Alagoas in Brazil. They don’t even have the educational technical means to administrate themselves. It’s a huge problem in Brazil.
Because of representation, we completely lack the drive to make things better—in many ways. So we want to make a ministry with young, bright people to try to get them together with those local mayors and get them to work better. And also bound them by obligations of increasing levels of basically everything. That is a way we could try to change the incentives in Brazilian political systems, right?
Wolf: Mm-hmm. And I understand this is sort of part of a general program of essentially centralizing the Brazilian state. The way I heard it explained was that Brazil has kind of not very much high human capital—people. And so the people you do have, you have to concentrate together—create one very competent government that’s then going to go and—and administer everything else.
Victor: Yeah. We estimate that in Brazil, there are many researchers on this, but a sufficient level of Portuguese and math are only like 10% of all Brazilians. Sufficient levels.
Wolf: Sufficient level of Portuguese.
Victor: Yeah. Of Portuguese and math—simultaneously. Yeah. So Brazil is able to do many great things. Embraer, Petrobras, there are many great Brazilian companies.
There are many great Brazilian cities, of course, but there is a big delta between the population. It’s very unequal. So we have this effort of trying to centralize and to better allocate human capital—throughout all the continent. In Northeast Brazil’s poorest region, it has the potential, many economical potentials, but it also has the worst elites in all of Brazil. So if we can get some right São Paulo guys right next to the mayor, bounding them to obligations of increasing social levels, maybe that could work.
Wolf: Right. Okay. So that’s one part of it, is this kind of problem of the localization, centralization, backwardness. You want to centralize Brazil effectively on a more technocratic ground. There’s also, I understand, a big crime problem—and with the favelas and the cartels and their connection even into politics.
I’d love to hear how you understand that part of the problem and what—Mission has to offer.
Fighting the cartels: Infiltration and open war (20:14)
Victor: Brazil’s constitution is from 1988, right? It was made right after the end of the military dictatorship. And also the international context by that time, it wasn’t still very socialist-friendly because the USSR hadn’t fallen, right? So it is very socialistic, and it has a lot of guarantees to every citizen. That in itself is not a problem, but it allowed crime in Brazil to get much bigger and much deadlier, right?
So by the ‘90s, Brazilian Comando Vermelho and PCC, they were small salesmen of marijuana and cocaine, right? Nowadays, they are international multibillion-dollar companies. They operate on many, many, many Brazilian sectors.
Wolf: These are the two—
Victor: Biggest ones
Wolf: big cartels. It’s the Red Commandos, and what was the other one?
Victor: PCC.
Wolf: PCC. What does it stand for?
Victor: Yeah. First Paulista Comando. No. Primeiro Comando da Capital. First Command of the Capital—in São Paulo.
One is São Paulo, the other one is Rio. We can talk about the differences—sociological differences between the two of those, because one is from Rio and one is from São Paulo. One is Paulista, one is Carioca, so they are very different in themselves. But they were small salesmen of drugs, and nowadays, they are huge—
Wolf: Business
Victor: business empires. And they control a big part of fuel in Brazil, gasoline—construction—cargo theft and cargo reselling of that, right?
Wolf: Right. Yeah, they hijack trucks.
Victor: Yeah, they hijack a lot of trucks in Rio and also in São Paulo. So they have become huge businessmen. They now are starting to infiltrate into the Brazilian government. Just the other month in Rio, nowadays we have five deputados estaduais now from the state, deputado from the state, congressmen—from the state arrested right now.
Wolf: For involvement in this.
Victor: Yeah, with Comando Vermelho. Right.
Wolf: Yeah. Well, it’s better than the Mexico situation, it sounds like—where the cartels are just killing—politicians.
Victor: Yeah. In Brazil, they are very effective in infiltrating the political class, and it’s a slippery slope in that sense, right? See, when you get the first one, the second is not so hard, the third one is not so hard. So we don’t have the legal means to combat that, I don’t think. With that constitution and that penal code, we don’t have any capability to fight them back.
So that’s why Partido Missão advocates to open war, formal war against cartels general.
Wolf: Yeah, I found that very interesting. I understand Renan basically wants to create the legal doctrine that because they’re running their own military and their own taxation systems—they are effectively foreign powers illegally occupying—Brazilian territory and should be treated as military targets.
Victor: Yeah. Just in Rio, I think one in seven Cariocas are living in controlled area by the tráfico. So it’s a lot of people. I have seen the metropolitan area of Rio, maybe two, three million people live in Comando Vermelho neighborhoods. So it’s bigger than many countries in the world, right?
And they enforce their own laws, their own customs, the music, the culture. They have everything of their own, right? They don’t allow the states to extract taxes or enforce anything, basically. So Renan, Partido Missão, for me, it’s very precise in the way they want to fight them, right? So there is an open war, right?
And intel also... There’s intel. We have to investigate better the infiltration they are doing, right? So we’re studying a lot of the anti-mafia laws in Italy. We have to bring some of those.
A lot of legislation from Singapore also is very interesting against infiltration and corruption in general. So those reforms have to come, but we also have to engage with the police, right? The police has to be bigger, better, better armed, more violent, if we want to have a chance. So it’s a—two parallel situations that we have to solve. I fear that Brazil in the next decade will be, if it isn’t already, but it will be the greatest world exporter of cocaine, because Trump is being very diligent about the Caribbean Sea nowadays.
He’s just striking people off and all. But, we also have routes that go downwards from the Andes into Brazil. And Brazil traditionally fuel the European market of cocaine. Right? But, nowadays, not only the Europeans are consuming much more, but also third world countries are developing a cocaine habit.
So Africans, Arabs, Chinese, Japanese, they buy more drugs nowadays. They want to keep buying more. So Brazil can be very strategic, not to just bypass the US and the Caribbean. You can send a ship straight from Brazil into Massachusetts or Connecticut or anything. And also we have the higher hand in exporting cocaine into the whole of the world.
So I fear how it can become more prosperous, the cocaine trade in Brazil.
Wolf: And that just empowers the cartels further.
Victor: Yeah. Greatly, because they do engage in many types of business, but there is nothing like shipping a ton of cocaine to the US. The profit margins, the way they earn it, would be too big, too great. They would have more power, more money, more influence also. So I fear that Brazil may become a narco state next decade or something.
Wolf: Yeah. Well, that’s what you guys are trying to fix—I guess.
Industrial development (26:42)
Victor: I mean, yeah.
Wolf: And I understand there’s also development priorities—that the mission has, as kind of the third big leg of the plan. Could you speak a little bit more to that in terms of industrialization and economic redevelopment?
Victor: Yeah. Brazil’s PT, the left party in Brazil, has had a socialistic rule since the 2000s, early 2000s. And Brazil’s first priorities has always been, since then, equality. So we don’t think of development or opportunity anymore. We are trying to mitigate poverty, mitigate misery—and all, but Brazil has become less relevant in the international grand scheme of things, particularly in the economy.
So Brazil used to have a large industrial base, in São Paulo, in Rio, Minas Gerais. We have some advantages like big iron ore deposits, have a lot of oil also. But we don’t seem to find a way to exploit that and turn that into prosperity, right? So, a big set of reform has to come to Brazil. So labor laws, environmental laws, indigenous people’s laws in Brazil—all of those, they try to get the country stagnant in favor of diversity or equality, right?
So traditionally Brazil has had very tough labor laws, very traditional. We call it CLT. It was inspired by fascistic legislation, the Carta del Lavoro—in Italy. So it’s very closed system of employing people in Brazil. We have to get rid of that—completely.
And also, decrease all legislation on other topics related to business development. And also Brazil has had a hard time keeping its accounts on check, right? So, it’s—
Wolf: Yeah, the financial problems—
Victor: Yeah, the finan—
Wolf: Many states have these sorts of problems.
Victor: Yeah. Yeah, it’s sometimes think it’s very related to democracy, right? Yeah.
Wolf: It’s hard to cut back the entitlements. And—
Victor: People mobilize politically a lot behind those. So we have to decrease social state. There is no other way. Some—
Wolf: Yeah. And what’s interesting, I guess, about your party, just the way you’re talking about these things, it’s very different from an American politician. American politicians, it’s like platitudes and—and very narrow, particular interest or something. But it’s, you’ve got a systematic approach to the problem, which is—again, the book, right? There’s this ideological, holistic approach to the whole problem.
Victor’s trajectory (29:53)
Wolf: So I find that very interesting. I guess it kind of comes down to just the way Renan has chosen to go at the problem. And, maybe it would be good now to turn more towards just that aspect, I guess. In particular, how you got involved. I think my understanding, you had your YouTube channel—and Renan basically approached you and said, “Hey, you guys should come on board. We’ve got this big program.”
But I would love for you to tell the story, kind of how did you get into politics at all? How did you get thinking about this stuff?
You’ve mentioned you used to be somewhat involved in the Bolsonaro people. Yeah, we’d love to hear your story, and how did you get pulled in, and what does that say about the nature of the project?
Victor: So, I graduated as a lawyer, and then I wasn’t happy with the—the ESG stuff, all the business environment in Brazil—how it was back in the day. And then I decided to start a business with my friend Eduardo Pessoa. It was a YouTube channel. I want to talk about history, philosophy, culture in general. So there wasn’t many channels in Brazil bringing this Nouveau Right way of talking about things—explaining things, so we did that.
And then I went into political commentary also. So—
Wolf: So you said Nouveau Right. Is that referring to the European New Right? Or, okay. Interesting.
Victor: The interesting stuff coming out of the US and Europe.
So I went into political commentary with some new ideas, some new theories that I read at Palladium, right? Many came through there. And then I have a habit of tweeting a lot. I like X a lot. So I was saying bullshit about the coup d’etat in South Korea.
It was two years ago. I was calling it the incel coup or something. It was a very funny story in South Korea. But Renan saw one of the tweets and he said, “That’s a nice take. We should talk more.”
And then we started talking on Twitter, on X, and eventually we became friends. I went to São Paulo to meet the guys. I had some political involvement with Bolsonaro’s party in Rio—but it was a terrible experience. It couldn’t be much worse. I was telling you, Wolf, people used to have prejudice against me because I had a superior degree, right?
They were like, “Oh, man, you’re a genius.” “How could you do this?” It was—
Wolf: The college degree. Yeah. It was too much for them. Which, yeah, that really says something about what politics is normally like in Brazil, I guess.
How Bolsonaro’s old right fumbled the ball (33:02)
Victor: Yeah. Like I was telling you, elites, they care about their own and the urban elites. Especially in Rio, they consider politics something dirty that they want to think about. They don’t care too much. So by consequence, politics in Brazil is very disengaged from people like me and people like Pessoa and all.
So, me somehow in a way had a great opportunity. There were a lot of young men willing to join politics, wanting to do something true. They had nowhere to go.
Wolf: Right. So how did that happen? Because it seems like Missão has attracted a lot of, maybe you have those urban elites or the urban upper middle class—and their children have gotten very interested in Missão, basically. And it’s the young men—from those demographics that are the backbone of Missão. And it’s very interesting to see that happening because in America and in Europe, we’re split between these ridiculous boomer parties, and we haven’t quite broken out into our own—political ambitions yet.
But it’s starting to get there. Especially, you go look in Britain, Restore Britain and so on. It’s very obvious that this—is a young people’s party. And there’s a few other examples like that where things are approaching, but it seems like things are most advanced along that kind of dimension in Brazil. And I’m curious how that happened.
What is it that—that—
Victor: Since the things I have seen in politics in Brazil propelled me to participate in. I saw Renan take down Dilma. I saw the rise of Bolsonaro. I have the frustration with Bolsonaro’s government. And then I saw Lula come back again.
And I was like—
Wolf: Yeah. Well, just the story, just for the American audience, the story of how Lula came back. I understand you mentioned that Senior Bolsonaro was willing to do anything to keep his son out of trouble. And I think the anything that he was willing to do—was let Lula out of prison. Is that right?
Victor: Yeah. Some Bolsonaristas at the time, they also thought that maybe with Lula coming back, Bolsonaro would become more popular. Stupid. It was said by Bolsonaro’s other son that is now living in the US. “So if Lula comes back, that’s great news for us. We have an enemy again.”
So it didn’t work out. Lula said he would go out of jail, run for presidency again, and win, and he did that. So it was very frustrating. We are in election time in Brazil again. I remember in 2018, 2016, people were ashamed to support PT.
If you called someone a petista, a supporter of PT, people would say, “No, not me. I’m not with Lula. I’m a leftist, but I’m not with Lula.” They would still press 13 on the ballot. But they wouldn’t say they were petistas.
In this election now, I see a lot of energy behind PT’s group. Again, of course, I live in Rio. I have an urban vision of the phenomena. There is a big support of PT amongst public servants and stuff. We have many of those in Rio, but people are proud to support Lula again.
That destroys me. We had the chance to maybe even outlaws PT in 2018, 2016. We could force them to make another party or try to break them up, and Bolsonaro wasn’t able to do anything. He exchanged his empire for his son. So that was very frustrating and then Lula won again.
I think there is a political wake up that happened between 2014, ‘16. I was 14 back then. And many of the guys that grew up with me also have this vision of this big frustration of everything could have gone great, but it didn’t. So Renan was there from the beginning. He was responsible for it back then.
He now resurfaced with a project. Why not? It sounded brilliant when I first saw it. The task of creating a new political party in Brazil seemed impossible by that time—because we have too many parties and the political class recognizes that, and they are trying to restrict. They are putting up legislation to restrict party creation in Brazil.
Last year, it was impossible maybe. But Renan could do it through tech, through talent, through meritocracy, and that was very stimulating. I’m running for Congress because I want to bring Renan’s campaign to Rio, right? In the end, I want to make sure that someone is doing it in a good level in my city, in my state. Okay.
So in the end, it always goes through that, right? So.
The need for leadership (38:31)
Wolf: Yeah. I guess I’m interested in how it feels on the day-to-day, maybe it’s these unknown unknowns of like—how the party is organized. It’s hard to ask a question. The question most directly would be like, what should the American audience, what would be most interesting from the success of Missão so far to the young American audience of the people who feel the same way in America—how should we kind of get started, right? And I’d—it’s hard because you maybe don’t see things on the ground in America.
We don’t see things on the ground in Brazil, so it’s hard to compare. But if you could venture to try to answer that question.
Victor: What was very important in Missão creation was the frustration with Bolsonaro. Maybe you have some of that with Trump nowadays.
Wolf: Yeah. I think in many ways Trump is the Bolsonaro of America. Yeah. He’s came in with much promise. Many people were enthusiastic, but obviously a lot of people also really didn’t like it, but, it’s done I think some good things and some bad things, and part of one of the things that’s been quite bad is the sort of level of corruption and—ineffectiveness, right?
And you see a lot of insider trading. You see all this sort of stuff. So people are frustrated. There’s certainly a faction of young people who are frustrated with Trump. But—some of that is this very, I would say, counterproductive stupidity.
They—just throw up their hands. They’re almost giving up at politics, sabotaging their allies. But it seems like you guys have done something much more productive, which is, okay—we’re not satisfied with that. Here’s something that’s even more systematic, more holistic. How?
How do we do this?
Victor: Yeah, maybe it starts with the frustration. You have a better vision of how to do it better, what’s wrong, what you should do different. And secondly, I should say you should have a leader.
Wolf: Yes. We need a leader. Yeah.
Victor: Yeah. It’s very stupid to say you have to find a leader because a leader appears. It’s—
Wolf: Yeah. Leaders are sent by God. You can’t just appoint them
Victor: you should look better for a leader, right? He’s there somewhere. The US is much bigger than Brazil in population, but, you should try to make something true and interesting. Be pragmatic. Try to do a full scope diagnosis of what’s wrong with the US.
Systematic analysis is the foundation of the new party (40:49)
Victor: That’s obvious for most of the people. Violence in Brazil—who could disagree, right? The way we are losing economic prominence—also obvious.
Wolf: No, but it still takes a lot of analysis to kind of get to the bottom of it, right?
Victor: Surely. To find a solution and to—better describe the problem, it’s very hard, actually. The Yellow Book had a team of like 2,000, 3,000 researchers voluntarily.
Wolf: 2,000 or 3,000 people were—Wow.
Victor: It took a lot of work. Not to find the problems, because the problems themselves are self-evident, mostly. Brazil is a hard place to live sometimes. But the how to understand and how to propose something better, that was hard. Maybe do that.
Wolf: Well, okay, that’s something to drill in on because, with The Students, maybe that’s part of our ambition, right? Is to give this—
Victor: Surely
Wolf: coherent view of what is our situation historically. And that’s something I’d love to put together. Here’s the picture, right? What’s wrong? What do we need to do?
That’s certainly the problem that we’re studying in a way. And so I’d love to hear more then about how that happened. How did The Yellow Book come together? How did that project get coordinated? Was it people writing articles or was it like teams kind of—researching a particular issue?
Or how did that actually... How do you put together a little yellow book?
Victor: We started it up with a magazine. Right. And—
Wolf: Started with a magazine.
Victor: That’s—
Wolf: Well, we’ve got a magazine, too.
Victor: Check. That one is done, right? So we started to assemble the best ideas. We did many groups of study in particular groups and also public police. A lot of police people in Brazil, public safety specialists, do a study group, understand what’s wrong, and go through with it.
I like to keep it voluntary, but coordinated by professional people, so have a lot of insights—have a diverse vision of the problem. I like to bring people who operate day to day on the area also. That’s very important to—the struggle of a policeman in Rio de Janeiro, that’s not obvious. That’s actually very hard. So try to bring those people together with the supervision of a paid specialist or a paid writer, academic preferably, and go theme by theme, man.
There’s no secret.
Wolf: And the academic sort of has that, or the specialist has that role of almost being the, not great to put it in these terms, but the sort of the political officer who integrates all the information—into a coherent vision.
Victor: Yeah. I think it’s very important to present yourself in a way we are very studious, coherent, good-intended, and pragmatic. We just want to make things better. What’s wrong with that, right? What makes things—
Wolf: Some people want to make things worse.
Victor: Yeah, sure. Many of them, but I think that’s an interesting way to present yourself. Society, not necessarily falling to, “I’m on the right,” “I’m on the left.” I want to get things done. That’s very important about Renan’s rhetoric.
That’s I want to make—Between Lula and Bolsonaro, who’s talking about Brazil in 30 years? In 40 years? 50 years, right? No one. Both of them will be dead, actually, right?
So...
Wolf: But you guys are all young. You are actually having to think about that.
Victor: I hope to have more 50 years—here in Brazil, working for the cause, right? So...
Wolf: All right. Do you have any final thoughts, things that you think that we haven’t covered? I’ve gone through all the obvious questions here.
Victor: No, we talk about a lot of interesting stuff. I would like to apologize if I’m too tired. Running a campaign is actually very hard.
Wolf: No, you guys are working crazy hard. It’s been hard to get time with you.
Victor: No, so I’m very tired. We are by the end of the campaign, but it was nice talking to you, Wolf. Thanks for having me, man.
Wolf: Thank you so much for coming on.
